Green Beauty Review: Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant (Gluten-Free, Paraben-Free, Aluminum-Free & Cruelty-Free Goodness!)


The following is an unpaid and unsolicited review of a product that I love.

Drugstore brand deodorants and antiperspirants typically include aluminum, parabens, talc, propylene glycol, triclosan, TEA, FD&C colors, and DEA, chemicals that have been linked to dermatitis, Alzheimer’s, cancer*, liver disease, kidney disease, antibiotic resistance, and disrupted thyroid function. It’s no wonder that many people that find themselves interested in avoiding toxic chemicals in their daily body care routine opt to try out a new deodorant first. It’s one of the easiest changes to make to your routine, and considering the hefty price tags on many other natural health and beauty products, often one of the cheapest changes, too.

If you’re like me, the “cheap” aspect was a huge selling point. Thank goodness, because I went through a lot of deodorants (and had a lot of – shall we say – aromatic days) on the road to finding the perfect potion for these ‘pits. I’ve spent the better part of the last ten years trying to find a natural deodorant/antiperspirant that offered a long term solution to odor & dampness, while also smelling good, being easy & comfortable to apply, and not causing my delicate underarm skin to break out in a rash. Along the way I tried a few great brands that I thought did the job pretty well, like Bubble & Bee’s Pit Putty and Luscious Lather’s Natural Deodorant. I also tried out plenty of other sworn-by products, like Thai Crystal (meh), coconut oil (great for using after shaving), apple cider vinegar, and more. However, nothing completely did the trick, and I always ended up going back to my drugstore brand.

Then I found Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant and fell in love. Most natural deodorants I’ve tried have a sticky, waxy feel to them (if you’ve ever tried Tom’s of Maine deodorants, you’ll know what I’m talking about). The ones that aren’t sticky are often the opposite – dry and crumbly – which is hell on delicate, easily-irritated skin. Schmidt’s is the perfect texture, very similar to that of Dove antiperspirant, but not in stick-form.

There’s a small learning curve that comes with scooping out and smearing on your own deodorant after years of using a deodorant stick, but it only takes a few days to get used to the routine. The jar comes with its own tiny spatula to scoop out a pea-sized bit of the cream, and the moment it comes in contact with your warm underarm, it very easily slides on, like a slightly dry lotion. What’s best is that the deodorant contains arrowroot powder, giving the mixture a dry finish once it’s applied – and helping absorb ‘pit moisture for hours. Once applied, there’s very little residue on your fingers, and what’s there is easy to wash or wipe off.

Aside from being easy to use, not giving me a rash, and doing a great job keeping my underarms from getting swampy, Schmidt’s smells amazing. The deodorant comes in five delightfully earthy scent combinations, including Lavender & Sage, Bergamot & Lime, Cedarwood & Juniper, Ylang Ylang & Calendula, and Fragrance Free. So far I’ve tried Lavender & Sage & Ylang Ylang & Calendula, and have found that both fragrances are very true to their names. I’m crazy about lavender, and am often disappointed that lavender products in the States don’t smell very much like they plant they’re supposed to be emulating. The essential oils used in Schmidt’s are of great quality, and it definitely shows (smells?). That being said, the scents are not overpowering. Once applied, the scent is faint, allowing you to use your chosen perfumes or essential oils without being afraid of mixing too many scents on your person.

Best of all, Schmidt’s is contains no toxic chemicals, and the brand is Cruelty-Free Certified, so no poor bunnies (or any other beloved creature) was harmed in the creation of this fantastic product. The following ingredients lists are from the two types of Schmidt’s I’ve tried thus far:

Lavender & Sage: Shea Butter, Baking Soda, Arrowroot Powder, Cocoa Seed Butter, Clary Sage Essential Oil, Lavender Essential Oil, Vitamin E & Hop Extract

Ylang Ylang & Calendula: Shea Butter, Baking Soda, Arrowroot Powder, Cocoa Seed Butter, Vitamin E, Ylang Ylang Essential Oil, Calendula Essential Oil & Hop Extract

If you’re looking to try out a natural, handcrafted deodorant that feels luxurious and actually works, I encourage you to give Schmidt’s a try. At $10 a jar, it’s about twice as expensive as most drugstore brands, but competitively priced for other natural brands. It’s free of parabens, aluminum, propylene glycol, phthalates, and for all of you gluten-free folks, you’ll be happy to learn that this is a safe product for you, too! You can find it online on Amazon, Anthropologie, Rodale’s, Pure Citizen, b-glowing, and Urban Outfitters, or check out Schmidt’s list of retailers by state.

*The FDA and the National Cancer Institute dispute the connection between deodorants and breast cancer, but studies have been inconclusive thus far.

10 Comments Add yours

  1. amy says:

    yay! I also have been on the search…for forever! My half cornstarch/half baking soda and dried lavender makes a huge mess, even though it proves to be mostly useful controlling my ‘natural perfume’. The latest was a bit of coconut oil and my Langouligrass Blend, it does pretty good. However, the oil on some fabrics could ruin it. I was really happy to see this review. Thanks anna. I will be trying this brand out.

    1. compassandquill says:

      Good! Glad you’re going to try it. I’m in love – hope you like it too, sweetness! XO.

  2. Lindsey says:

    Awesome! I have tried tom’s, jasons and soapwalla, all of which gave me crazy red and irritated armpits. Thanks so much for this review I’m going to order this brand today!

    1. compassandquill says:

      Don’t you just hate that? This is the 1st brand that hasn’t given me a single problem – I’m so in love. But it’s always a trial and error thing, since everyone’s chemistry is a bit different. Another thing I’ve found to really work after armpit rashes in the past is to use coconut oil for a day or two. It works as a natural deodorant and helps sooth the irritated skin very well, plus it smooths on so easily that you don’t hurt yourself more in the process. I’m such a sensitive soul, lol!

      Also, Bubble & Bee has a great post about armpit irritation that might interest you:

  3. Marcelle says:

    I’ve heard that baking soda contains aluminum. Is there anyway of knowing for sure that the baking soda used in this product is aluminum free? Thanks!

    1. compassandquill says:

      Hey Marcelle, if I were you, I’d contact Schmidt’s directly to ask. They’re really friendly, and that’s probably a question that they get all the time. However, on their page, they specifically state that the product is aluminum-free, so that’s somewhere to start. Also, if you’re into health-conscious beauty products, you’ll probably love Crunchy Betty’s blog. Here’s a post she wrote about baking soda and aluminum that’s a pretty interesting read. She’s got tons of great recipes for beauty and body products on her site, too 🙂 Have fun!

  4. Bobbi says:

    I’ve heard from multiple sources that Lavilin is a very safe and reputable brand. Just bought some for the first time 2 weeks ago. Will re-post later in the summer to let you know how it goes!

    1. compassandquill says:

      I’ve heard that, too. Good luck!

  5. Jamie Locke says:

    Schmidts is good for me but I can’t get my husband to use it because it smells “to girly”. We just found him a brand called Uncle Jack’s Deodorant and he loves it. They sell it on amazon or

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s